🔗 Share this article

As a critic, I've made plenty of errors to experience quiet satisfaction when a verdict is vindicated. In the early 80s, I wrote excitedly about a new Stephen Sondheim musical which I attended during early showings in NYC. Reviled by reviewers and rejected by theatergoers, it then closed shortly after its premiere. Jump ahead to recent years, the very same musical enjoyed a year-long Broadway engagement, earned four Tony honors and received glowing reviews.

Transforming a Classic

While I say "the production being unchanged, this isn't entirely true. Adapted from a Depression-era work by the celebrated theatrical partnership, it remains the same story unfolding from end to beginning. The narrative explores deteriorating connections centering around an ambitious musician and movie producer named Franklin Shepard. Throughout the production, he reminisces across his years and sees the gradual deterioration of both his creative partnership with dramatist Charley along with their shared bond with author Mary.

Production Changes

In the wake of the musical's poor reception four decades ago, Sondheim and writer George Furth implemented significant revisions. The show doesn't start with a student song written by Franklin but rather commences with a lavish gathering marketing his newest film achievement. The selection of performers has also evolved. The initial production's actors included inexperienced talent who initially acted middle age characters and eased naturally into youth throughout the performance. Modern stagings typically feature mature actors who straddle the years with minimal adjustments.

The strength of the storytelling rests in its capacity to connect uniquely for every audience member. Similar to backwards-told stories, the production shows how life inevitably involves concessions, modifications and feelings of absence.

Musical Innovation

This remarkable show features Sondheim quietly getting even against his detractors. One memorable scene where a show business veteran lectures the young protagonists about the necessity to compose catchy songs in stage shows, featuring the notable statement: "I'll let you know if Strandever creates a popular work." The ultimate irony exists because that Sondheim's creation actually features multiple cherished compositions including Old Friends, Good Thing Going and the signature song that developed as persistent musical memories among loyal fans.

Actor Portrayals

Should there be a reasonable objection about the production, it involves the main character Franklin lacking audience connection. But, in this staging, the principal actor intelligently portrays him not as an egomaniac monster but more as a doomed idealist who moves through existence repeatedly picking the simplest solution. The supporting cast excellently embody Mary's unfulfilled romantic longings, while the most eye-catching performance emerges from the thespian portraying Charley, who gives the part both nervous tension and passionate belief in art's power to improve lives.

Continuing Influence

Whether Merrily itself achieves this transformation stays with viewers to personally determine. The current production remains a constant joy and powerfully illustrates precisely how a famous flop has transformed into a palpable hit. The recorded production of this celebrated adaptation offers audiences the opportunity to enjoy this extraordinary evolution firsthand.